Jury Rules NYT Not Liable in Sarah Palin Defamation Lawsuit
Jury Rules NYT Not Liable in Sarah Palin Defamation Lawsuit
A federal jury in Manhattan on Tuesday found the New York Times not liable for allegedly defaming Sarah Palin in a 2017 editorial about gun control, dealing the former Republican vice presidential candidate a second loss at trial.
The verdict came in a retrial of Palin's case, after a federal appeals court threw out a 2022 verdict in the Times' favor. Palin, 61, who also served as Alaska's governor, sued the newspaper and former editorial page editor James Bennet over a June 14, 2017, article that wrongly suggested she may have incited a January 2011 mass shooting in an Arizona parking lot.
Six people were killed and Democrat Rep. Gabby Giffords was seriously wounded in the attack.
Bennet said he was under deadline pressure when he added language to "America's Lethal Politics" that linked the attack to a map from Palin's political action committee that put Giffords and other Democrats under crosshairs.
The Times quickly acknowledged its mistake and apologized, publishing a correction 14 hours after the editorial appeared online.
Lawyers for Palin said that wasn't enough because the backtracking didn't mention her by name.
In her closing argument, Times' lawyer Felicia Ellsworth alluded to the high burden that Palin, a public figure, had in order to hold the newspaper liable.
"To win this case, Governor Palin needs to prove that the New York Times and James Bennet did not care about the truth," she said. "There has not been one shred of evidence showing anything other than an honest mistake."
Palin lawyer Ken Turkel said it was more than that.
"This is not an honest mistake about a passing reference" to Palin, he said in his closing argument. "For her, it was a life-changer." Palin lost her first trial in February 2022, but the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan last August said the verdict was tainted by several rulings from the presiding judge. The case had long been viewed by Palin and other conservatives as a possible vehicle to overturn the 1964 U.S. Supreme Court landmark New York Times v. Sullivan.
In that case, the court said that to win a defamation case, a public figure must demonstrate that an offending statement was made with "actual malice," meaning with knowledge it was false or with reckless disregard as to whether it was false. The 2nd Circuit, however, said Palin waived the argument by waiting too long to challenge the "actual malice" standard. President Donald Trump has also questioned the standard.
Palin was Alaska's governor from 2006 to 2009, and ran with late Republican Sen. John McCain of Arizona in his unsuccessful 2008 White House run. Democrat Barack Obama and his vice presidential pick Joe Biden won that race.
Warren Buffett, 94, Stepping Down as Berkshire Hathaway CEO
May 4, 2025
3 min
Sovereignty Wins 2025 Kentucky Derby
May 4, 2025
<1 min
Trump Proposes Deploying US Troops to Mexico to Fight Drug Cartels
May 4, 2025
2 min
British Police Foil Terrorist Attack – 5 Arrested
May 4, 2025
1 min
Big Win for Nigel Farage and UK Reform Party
May 4, 2025
3 min
Trump Posts AI Image of Himself as Pope
May 4, 2025
2 min
3 Corrections Officers Stabbed by MS-13 Gang Members
May 4, 2025
1 min
Left-Wing Government Wins Australian Election
May 3, 2025
3 min
Stephen Miller Emerges as Top Contender for National Security Adviser
May 3, 2025
1 min
Court Audio: Abrego Garcia’s Wife Says He’d ‘Wake Up and Beat Me’
May 3, 2025
3 min
Trump Admin Reaches Settlement with Family of Ashli Babbitt
May 3, 2025
4 min
Israel Launches Airstrikes Near Syrian Presidential Palace
May 3, 2025
2 min
Woman Who Called Kid N-Word Raises Over $500,000 to Relocate
May 3, 2025
3 min
Transportation Dept. Discovers $54M in Woke Grants — And Ends Them
May 3, 2025
2 min
Trump Ends Tariff Loophole That Enabled Flood of Cheap Chinese Goods
May 3, 2025
7 min
John Ratcliffe to Fire 1,200 CIA Employees
May 3, 2025
2 min
Germany: 1 Killed and 7 Injured After Car Drives Into Crowd
May 3, 2025
1 min
AfD Classified as Extreme-Right by German Intelligence
May 3, 2025
3 min
Trump Asks Supreme Court to Allow DOGE Access Social Security Data
May 3, 2025
2 min
Prince Harry Loses Court Battle Over Security Protection
May 3, 2025
1 min