Judge Boasberg Rules He Could Hold Trump Admin in Criminal Contempt
Judge Boasberg Rules He Could Hold Trump Admin in Criminal Contempt
US District Judge James Boasberg ruled Wednesday that “probable cause exists” to hold Trump administration officials in criminal contempt for violating his orders in mid-March halting the use of the Alien Enemies Act to deport Venezuelan gang members.
The situation has been a major political and legal flashpoint for the Trump White House in its efforts to carry out a historic deportation campaign, especially in mid-March when it sent three planes of migrants to a prison in El Salvador. That same day, Boasberg held an emergency hearing and told the administration to pause the migrant removals and order the return of deportation flights back to the US.
“The Court ultimately determines that the Government’s actions on that day demonstrate a willful disregard for its Order, sufficient for the Court to conclude that probable cause exists to find the Government in criminal contempt,” Boasberg wrote in a 46-page ruling detailing his decision.
“The Court does not reach such conclusion lightly or hastily; indeed, it has given Defendants ample opportunity to rectify or explain their actions,” he added. “None of their responses has been satisfactory.”
Test of Trump compliance with the courts
The ruling from Boasberg comes as the Trump administration continues to test how far it can push its compliance with court orders it disagrees with.
The administration has repeatedly said that federal trial-level courts, especially, lack the authority to issue orders that could encroach on the president’s immigration policy decisions.
“The Constitution does not tolerate willful disobedience of judicial orders – especially by
officials of a coordinate branch who have sworn an oath to uphold it,” Boasberg, an appointee of former President Barack Obama, wrote in his ruling.
In the case at hand, the Supreme Court ultimately said earlier this month that the migrants who challenged Trump’s use of the Alien Enemies Act to quickly carry out deportations of alleged members of a Venezuelan gang brought their case in the wrong court.
The court’s 5-4 ruling requires those wanting to bring such challenges to rely on a complicated and rarely successful legal process known as habeas corpus, and to potentially file those claims in some of the most conservative federal courts in the nation.
Despite the high court’s decision, Boasberg said in his ruling, it’s a longstanding concept in the justice system that a party that chooses to disobey a court order before it is wiped away by a subsequent court order can still be punished.
Boasberg also cast doubt on the administration’s invocation of the state secrets privilege to avoid giving him a number of details on the flights that he wanted as he worked to decide whether his commands had been violated. The judge, however, ultimately determined that the information the government sought to shield wasn’t necessary to reach his conclusion in the contempt issue.
Next steps
Boasberg, who is the chief judge of the federal trial-level court in DC, outlined the next steps in the contempt proceeding, since it is not proven yet beyond a reasonable doubt that the administration committed criminal contempt.
Boasberg says he wants sworn statements first from people who can attest to the officials making the decisions not to turn the planes around as they carried migrants to El Salvador on March 15.
Then, Boasberg says, if those statements aren’t satisfactory to him, he will ask for live witnesses to testify at hearings or depositions.
The judge could then, he says, ask the Justice Department to prosecute Trump administration officials, or he could appoint an attorney as a special prosecutor.
India Launches Missile Strikes Against Pakistan
May 7, 2025
5 min
US and China to Hold Trade Talks in Switzerland This Weekend
May 7, 2025
2 min
Supreme Court Allow Trans Military Ban
May 7, 2025
3 min
GOP Senator Kills Trump’s Pick for DC US Attorney
May 7, 2025
5 min
Top Takeaways from Trump’s Meeting with Canada’s Mark Carney
May 7, 2025
5 min
UC Berkeley Stabbing: Police Hunt 3 Suspects
May 7, 2025
<1 min
House Report: FBI ‘butchered’ 2017 congressional baseball shooting probe
May 7, 2025
8 min
Friedrich Merz Wins 2nd Vote to Become Germany's Leader
May 7, 2025
4 min
Trump: Houthis ‘Don’t Want to Fight Anymore,’ US Will Stop Bombings
May 6, 2025
3 min
Trump Ordered To Admit Thousands Of Refugees
May 6, 2025
3 min
Israeli Military Fully Disables Yemen’s Main Airport with Strikes
May 6, 2025
2 min
Hegseth Orders 20% Cut of Top Pentagon Generals
May 6, 2025
1 min
Paul Tudor Jones: Stock Market Will Hit New Lows Even If Tariffs Cut
May 6, 2025
1 min
IDENTIFIED: Lady Gaga Bomb Suspect Was Deported From US Last Month
May 6, 2025
2 min
‘Landmark Study’ Led by UNLV Shows New Path to Treat, Prevent Autism
May 6, 2025
3 min
Army Suspends Blackhawk Flights to Pentagon After New Scare
May 6, 2025
2 min
Newark Airport Lost Radar and Radio Communication with Pilots for 90 Seconds
May 6, 2025
3 min
Brian Kemp Won’t Run for US Senate in 2026
May 6, 2025
2 min
Trump to Super-Charge Deportations Using Local Cops
May 6, 2025
2 min
Mike Myers, Michael B. Jordan First Celebs Named in Diddy Trial
May 6, 2025
3 min